Society6 vs. Fine Art America: A Comparison for Artists

Society6 vs. Fine Art America: The Ultimate Artist Showdown

by

Navigating the world of print-on-demand (POD) platforms can be overwhelming for artists. Two of the biggest names in the game, Society6 and Fine Art America, offer incredible opportunities to sell your work to a global audience without ever touching a shipping box. But they are fundamentally different platforms built for different types of artists and goals. Choosing the right one can be the difference between a thriving side business and a gallery of unseen work.

This comprehensive guide breaks down the critical differences between these two giants. We’ll dive deep into their product offerings, commission structures, target audiences, and what real artists are saying about their experiences. By the end, you’ll have a clear understanding of which platform is the perfect fit for your unique artistic vision.

Table of Contents

At a Glance: Society6 vs. Fine Art America

Before we get into the details, let’s start with a high-level overview.

  • Fine Art America: As the name suggests, this platform is primarily focused on, well, fine art america. It’s a marketplace designed for photographers, painters, and digital artists who want to sell high-quality prints and wall art. The emphasis is on the art itself, making it a go-to for customers looking for professional-grade decor.
  • Society6: This platform positions itself as a creative hub for artists to put their work on a vast array of lifestyle products. Think tapestries, phone cases, furniture, and apparel. It caters to a younger, trend-driven audience looking for unique designs to express their personality. Many consider it a top choice among sites like redbubble and society6.

Deep Dive: The Core Philosophies

To truly understand the difference, you need to know what is fine art america versus Society6 at their core. The fineartamerica platform operates like a traditional art gallery and fulfillment center combined. The artist is the main brand, and the customer is typically there to buy a piece of art to hang on their wall. The entire fine art america website is built around discovering artists and their collections of gallery-worthy work.

In contrast, Society6 is a design-forward marketplace. While artists are celebrated, the design is often the star. Customers might search for “botanical print” and fall in love with a pattern, then decide to buy it on a comforter, a shower curtain, and a tote bag. It’s less about collecting a specific artist’s work and more about integrating unique designs into daily life. Many artists looking for stores like society6 are seeking this kind of product diversity.

Artist Control & Pricing: Who Holds the Power?

This is one of the most significant points of difference and a deciding factor for many artists.

With Fine Art America, you have complete control over your profit margins. The platform sets the fine art america base prices for each product (e.g., a 24×36 canvas print might have a base price of $50). You then add your markup on top of that. If you add a $25 markup, the final price is $75, and your profit is $25. This means your fine art america commission is whatever you decide it to be. This model directly answers the question, how much commission does fine art america take? In reality, they take their base price, and you get the rest.

Society6 operates on a fixed-commission model for most products. Artists typically earn 10% of the retail price. While you can set your own prices for art prints and canvas prints, the majority of their extensive product catalog has this fixed 10% royalty. This makes pricing simple, but it offers far less control over your earnings potential.

Product Catalog & Quality: Prints vs. Lifestyle Goods

Both platforms are known for quality, but their strengths lie in different areas.

When it comes to wall art, the fine art america print quality is widely regarded as industry-leading. They offer an incredible range of papers, canvas options, frames, and finishes, fulfilled by a global network of professional print labs. For artists who want to fine art america sell photos or high-resolution paintings, this is a major draw. The focus is squarely on providing a gallery-quality product.

Society6 also offers good quality prints, but their true strength is the sheer breadth of their product catalog. From furniture and bedding to tech accessories and apparel, they allow your art to become part of a customer’s entire lifestyle. If your work is pattern-based or graphic, seeing it on a diverse range of products can be incredibly rewarding. Many artists seek out an alternative to society6 but find few that can match this product variety.

Audience & Marketing: Finding Your Buyers

You can’t sell art without an audience, and the customer bases on these platforms are distinct.

The audience for fine art in america often includes interior designers, serious art collectors, and homeowners looking for a statement piece. They are searching for art, not just a design. This means that to succeed, you need to be strategic with your titles, descriptions, and the use of fine art keywords to ensure your work gets discovered in a crowded marketplace.

Society6’s audience is generally younger, trend-conscious, and active on social media. They are looking for unique designs that reflect their personal style. Marketing on platforms like Instagram and Pinterest is often crucial for success here. When considering society6 alternatives, artists often look for platforms with a similar demographic.

E-commerce & Integrations: Selling Your Way

For artists who want to sell directly from their own website, FAA has a clear advantage. The number one question many sellers ask is, does fine art america integrate with shopify? The answer is yes. Fine Art America offers a robust Shopify app that allows you to embed a full-featured shopping cart directly on your site, giving you a white-label solution to sell their products under your own brand.

Society6 does not offer this kind of direct integration. While you can link to your Society6 shop from your personal website, the customer will always complete the transaction on Society6.com.

Real Talk: Fine Art America Reviews by Artists

So, what’s the verdict from artists on the ground? A look at fine art america reviews reveals a consistent picture. Many artists praise the platform’s print quality, control over pricing, and powerful e-commerce tools. A common theme in any fine art america review is the satisfaction with the professional-grade products.

However, a recurring point in fine art america artist reviews is the sheer amount of self-promotion required. You can’t just upload your art and expect sales to roll in. This is a sentiment echoed in many fine art america seller reviews. Some fine art america reviews by sellers also note that the platform’s interface can feel a bit dated compared to more modern sites. Looking at a fine art america review reddit thread will often show a mix of artists who make a great living and others who struggle to be seen.

Ultimately, reading a selling on fine art america review makes it clear: success is tied directly to your marketing efforts. We expect these points to remain consistent in fine art america reviews as well. The consensus from fine art america reviews by artists is that it’s a powerful tool if you’re willing to put in the work to build your brand.

Exploring Alternatives to Both Platforms

Of course, the POD world is vast. If neither of these platforms feels quite right, there are many fine art america alternatives.

  • Etsy: For those who want more of a hands-on approach or sell original pieces alongside prints. Many artists debate fine art america vs etsy.
  • Redbubble: Very similar to Society6, offering a wide range of products with a focus on fan art and pop culture designs.
  • Saatchi Art: A curated online gallery for artists who want to sell original works and limited-edition prints to a high-end clientele. It’s often seen as one of the key alternatives to fine art america.
  • Printful/Printify: These are pure fulfillment services that integrate with your own e-commerce store. You have total brand control, but you also handle all the marketing and website management.

If you are looking for any site like fineartamerica, Saatchi Art is a strong contender. If you need sites like society6 or websites like society6, Redbubble and Zazzle are your best bets.

The Final Verdict: Which Platform is Right for You?

So, after all this, is fine art america worth it? The answer depends entirely on you.

Choose Fine Art America if:

  • You are a photographer, painter, or fine artist.
  • Your primary goal is to sell high-quality wall art.
  • You want complete control over your pricing and profit margins.
  • You have a marketing plan and are prepared to drive your own traffic.
  • You want to integrate a professional print shop into your own Shopify website.

Choose Society6 if:

  • You are a graphic designer, illustrator, or pattern artist.
  • You want to see your designs on a massive range of lifestyle products.
  • You prefer a simple, fixed-royalty system and don’t want to worry about pricing.
  • Your art style aligns with a younger, trend-focused audience.

Ultimately, the question of is fine art america a good place to sell comes down to your goals. For serious artists focused on prints, the answer is often a resounding yes. If you ask, is fine art america good? for a pattern designer, the answer might be less certain. The process of selling on fine art america is straightforward, but profitability requires dedication.

Frequently Asked Questions

What percentage does Fine Art America take?
Fine Art America does not take a percentage. Instead, they set a base price for each product. The artist then adds their own markup, which is their profit. For example, if the base price is $40 and you set the final price to $60, you keep the $20 markup. So, an artist’s fine art america reviews by artists often praise this transparent pricing model.

is fine art america a reputable company?
Yes, is fine art america a reputable company is a common question, and the answer is that it is one of the largest and most respected art marketplaces in the world. It has been in operation since 2006 and fulfills millions of orders for a global customer base. The general consensus from both artist and customer fineartamerica review feedback is positive regarding their legitimacy and product quality.

how does fine art america work?
The process for an artist trying to understand how does fine art america work is simple: 1) You create a free account and upload your digital images. 2) You choose which products you want to sell (e.g., canvas prints, posters, greeting cards). 3) You set your own prices for each product by adding a markup to the base price. 4) When a customer buys your product, Fine Art America handles the printing, framing, matting, packaging, and shipping. They then pay you your markup.

how does fine art america pay you?
The process of how does fine art america pay you is straightforward. Payments are sent out on the 15th of each month for all sales that occurred before the 15th of the previous month (allowing for a 30-day return window). You can receive your payment via PayPal or check.

Who owns Fine Art America?
A key question for those wanting to know more about the company is who owns fine art america. The company was founded by Sean Ginat and is still privately owned. It is part of the parent company Pixels.com.

Where is Fine Art America located?
For those wondering where is fine art america located, its corporate headquarters are in Santa Monica, California. However, they operate a global network of 16 manufacturing facilities in five different countries to ensure efficient production and shipping worldwide.

What about fine art america shipping costs?
The fine art america shipping costs are paid by the customer at checkout. The cost is calculated based on the size and weight of the order and the destination. Artists do not have to pay for shipping.

Can I get a fine art america discount code?
Yes, artists can create their own promotions and offer a fine art america discount code for their work through their seller dashboard. Fine Art America also runs site-wide promotions, especially around holidays.

How is the fine art america customer service?
Based on public reviews, the fine art america customer service is generally considered responsive and helpful for both buyers and sellers. They offer support via email and have a detailed help section on their website to resolve common issues.