Zillow vs. Competitors Redfin, Realtor.com & More

Zillow vs. The Competition: A Deep Dive Into the Top Real Estate Sites

by

Navigating the world of online real estate can feel like stepping into a bustling city with countless streets to explore. Dozens of websites and apps promise to help you find your next home, but they aren’t all built the same. At the center of this digital metropolis stands Zillow, a name so dominant it has become synonymous with real estate itself. For nearly two decades, Zillow has empowered users with data and tools, evolving from a simple home valuation site into a comprehensive "housing super app."

But in a landscape this competitive, how does the giant truly stack up against its rivals? From brokerage-hybrids like Redfin to industry-backed powerhouses like Realtor.com, the choices are plentiful. This guide will break down the key differences and similarities in the ultimate Zillow vs. competitors showdown. We’ll explore everything from home value estimates and business models to the user experience, giving you the clarity you need to navigate your real estate journey.

Table of Contents

What Is Zillow and How Does It Work?

Before diving into comparisons, it’s essential to understand what is Zillow at its core. Founded with the mission to empower people with information, Zillow has become the most visited and trusted name in residential real estate. In fact, "Zillow" is searched more often than the term "real estate." This isn’t just a website; it’s an end-to-end ecosystem designed to support buyers, sellers, renters, and real estate professionals through every step of their journey.

So, what is Zillow and how does it work? Zillow operates as a "housing super app," providing a suite of integrated tools:

  • For Buyers: Users can search millions of listings, take 3D Home® tours, understand their budget with the BuyAbility tool, and connect with local Zillow Premier Agent® partners.
  • For Sellers: Zillow provides tools to estimate their home’s value, track market trends, and use features like Zillow Showcase to attract buyers’ attention.
  • For Renters: The platform offers tools to manage applications, sign leases, and even pay rent online, with options to report on-time payments to help build credit.

At the heart of the consumer experience is the Zestimate®. If you’ve ever asked, "what is my zestimate?" you’ve used Zillow’s proprietary home valuation model. It’s a computer-generated estimate of a home’s market value based on public data, MLS information, and user-submitted facts. While it’s a powerful starting point, Zillow is clear that the Zestimate is not an appraisal. Its accuracy is impressive, with a nationwide median error rate of just 1.94% for on-market homes, though this can vary based on data availability in a specific area. Understanding what is zestimate is key to using the platform effectively.

Zillow vs. Trulia: A Tale of Two Sisters

One of the most common comparisons is Trulia vs Zillow. What many users don’t realize is that this isn’t a true rivalry. Zillow Group acquired Trulia in 2015, making them part of the same family. So, are trulia and zillow owned by the same company? Yes, they are. But the question of is trulia and zillow the same has a more nuanced answer.

Before the acquisition, they were direct zillow competitors. Today, they operate as distinct brands under one corporate umbrella. The core listing data you find on both sites is largely identical because they pull from the same sources. The primary difference between zillow and trulia lies in the user experience and data presentation.

  • Zillow: Focuses on the "super app" concept, integrating financing, agent connections, and a full suite of tools into a seamless journey. Its signature feature is the Zestimate®.
  • Trulia: Often praised for its deep focus on neighborhood data. It provides layers of information on crime rates, school ratings, commute times, and local amenities, giving users a granular feel for what it’s like to live in a specific area.

So, which is better zillow or trulia? The choice between zillow or trulia better comes down to personal preference. If you want an all-in-one platform that guides you from search to closing, Zillow is built for that. If your priority is diving deep into neighborhood specifics before anything else, you might prefer Trulia’s interface. Since you now know who owns trulia and zillow, you can be confident the underlying property information is reliable on both. Given their shared data, the debate over is zillow or trulia more accurate is moot; they are equally accurate.

Zillow vs. Redfin: The Brokerage vs. The Marketplace

The Redfin vs Zillow debate is one of the most significant in the online real estate world because it highlights a fundamental difference in business models. While they are often seen as direct zillow competitors, they operate in fundamentally different ways. The question of are redfin and zillow the same is a definitive no.

Here’s the breakdown of the difference between zillow and redfin:

  • Zillow’s Model (The Marketplace): Zillow is a media and technology company. It provides a platform with listings and data, and its primary revenue stream from agents comes from the Zillow Premier Agent program. Zillow connects interested buyers and sellers with local real estate agents from a wide range of brokerages who advertise on the platform. It’s an open marketplace.
  • Redfin’s Model (The Brokerage): Redfin is a licensed real estate brokerage. It employs its own team of salaried agents. When you connect with an agent on Redfin, you are working directly with a Redfin employee, not an agent from another company. This is why some ask is redfin better than zillow—it offers a different service model.

Home Value Estimates: Zillow Zestimate vs. Redfin Estimate
A major point of contention is the redfin vs zillow estimate. Both are automated valuation models (AVMs) that provide a starting point for a home’s value.

  • Zillow Zestimate: Has a published nationwide median error rate of 1.94% for on-market homes and 7.06% for off-market homes. Its accuracy depends heavily on the amount of available data.
  • Redfin Estimate: Uses its own proprietary algorithm. Redfin also publishes its accuracy rates, which can be compared market by market.

So, is zillow or redfin more accurate? The answer to which is more reliable redfin or zillow depends entirely on the specific market and even the specific property. The constant question of how accurate are redfin and zillow estimates has no universal answer, but both platforms provide data on their respective accuracy. Many users compare the zillow redfin estimate to get a potential value range. The key takeaway is that neither is a substitute for a professional appraisal.

Listings and iBuying
Generally, do redfin and zillow have the same listings? Yes, for the most part. Both platforms pull their listing data primarily from local Multiple Listing Services (MLS), so their inventory of agent-listed homes is very similar.

For a time, both companies were also direct competitors in the iBuying space with RedfinNow vs Zillow Offers. Zillow has since sunset its Zillow Offers program, while Redfin continues to operate its iBuying arm.

Ultimately, deciding what’s better redfin or zillow depends on what you’re looking for. Do you prefer the wide selection of agents from various brokerages that Zillow offers, or the standardized service model of working with a Redfin agent? That is the core of the zillow vs redfin which is better debate.

Zillow vs. Realtor.com: The Industry Powerhouses

Another major matchup is Zillow vs Realtor.com. These two are titans in the online real estate portal space, but they have very different origins and affiliations, which influences how they operate.

The key difference between zillow and realtor com is their affiliation. Zillow is an independent, publicly traded technology company. Realtor.com is the official consumer-facing website of the National Association of Realtors (NAR), operated by Move, Inc., a subsidiary of News Corp.

Here’s how they compare:

  • Listings Data: Both platforms source the vast majority of their listings from MLS feeds. Because of its official NAR affiliation, Realtor.com often claims to have the most accurate and up-to-date MLS data. However, Zillow also has direct data-sharing agreements with hundreds of MLSs and brokerages nationwide, making their listing data highly comprehensive and timely as well. So, do zillow and realtor have the same listings? In most cases, yes.
  • Home Value Estimates: When comparing realtor vs zillow estimates, both platforms provide automated valuations. Zillow has its well-known Zestimate, while Realtor.com uses a blend of three different AVMs to provide its estimates. The question of which is more accurate realtor or zillow is similar to the Redfin debate—it’s market-dependent, and both are merely estimates.
  • Agent Leads: For real estate professionals, the competition between zillow leads vs realtor com leads is fierce. Both are major sources of business for agents. Zillow’s Premier Agent program is a cornerstone of its business, connecting agents with active buyers. The provided data shows that agents using Premier Agent close, on average, 60% more transactions. Realtor.com has its own suite of advertising products, like its Connections℠ Plus program, to connect agents with consumers.
  • Overall Experience: The choice between zillow vs realtor often comes down to user preference. Zillow has branded itself as the "housing super app," with a deep integration of services like Zillow Home Loans. Realtor.com leverages its NAR connection to provide a trusted, industry-backed experience. Deciding what’s better zillow or realtor com depends on which ecosystem you find more intuitive and helpful for your needs.

Redfin vs. Zillow vs. Realtor.com: The Ultimate Showdown

When you put the three biggest names side-by-side, the distinctions become even clearer. The redfin vs zillow vs realtor debate is about choosing between three different philosophies for online real estate.

Feature Zillow Redfin Realtor.com
Business Model Media & Tech Platform Real Estate Brokerage Official Site of NAR
Agent Interaction Connects with partner agents from various brokerages Connects with in-house, salaried Redfin agents Connects with advertising agents from various brokerages
Primary Data Source MLS Feeds, Public Records MLS Feeds, Public Records MLS Feeds (NAR Affiliated)
Key Feature Zestimate®, "Housing Super App" Ecosystem Discounted Commissions, Salaried Agents NAR Affiliation, Claimed Data Accuracy

So, is zillow redfin or realtor more accurate? Again, there is no single winner. Listing data accuracy is high across all three. For home value estimates, their accuracy fluctuates by market. The best approach is to view all three estimates to establish a potential range, but always rely on a comparative market analysis (CMA) from a real estate professional or a formal appraisal. The zillow vs redfin vs realtor choice is less about raw data and more about which platform’s tools and service model align best with your goals.

Zillow vs. iBuyers: Opendoor, Offerpad, and a Shifting Landscape

For a period, a major part of Zillow’s business was its iBuying division, Zillow Offers. This put it in direct competition with specialized iBuyer companies. The core question for sellers became Opendoor vs Zillow or Offerpad vs Zillow.

The iBuyer model involves companies making near-instant cash offers on homes, allowing sellers to bypass the traditional listing process. What is Zillow Offers? It was Zillow’s version of this service, where they would buy homes directly from sellers, make minor repairs, and then list them for sale.

However, in late 2021, Zillow announced it was shutting down its Zillow Offers program. While this was a significant strategic shift, understanding its history is crucial to understanding the current market. Zillow’s exit left the field to primary zillow offers competitors like Opendoor and Offerpad. Today, when considering an iBuyer, the comparison is now opendoor vs offerpad vs zillow‘s current model, which focuses on connecting sellers with Zillow Premier Agent partners who can help them with a traditional sale, rather than a direct cash offer from Zillow itself.

Other Zillow Competitors and Alternatives

While Zillow, Redfin, and Realtor.com are the big three, there are many other sites like zillow that cater to different needs. If you’re looking for real estate sites other than zillow, here are a few noteworthy zillow competitors:

  • Homes.com: Now owned by CoStar, homes com vs zillow has become a more prominent comparison as Homes.com invests heavily in becoming a major consumer portal.
  • Compass: The compass vs zillow comparison is interesting because Compass is a tech-forward brokerage, similar to Redfin, but often focused on the luxury market.
  • Local Brokerage Websites: Never underestimate the power of local brokerage sites, which often have deep insights into their specific communities.
  • Niche Sites: There are also specialized platforms. For instance, loopnet vs zillow is a key distinction for investors, as LoopNet focuses exclusively on commercial real estate, whereas Zillow is centered on residential properties.
  • Agent-Matching Services: Sites like homelight vs zillow focus more on connecting you with an agent rather than on the property search itself.

Whether you’re exploring apps similar to zillow or websites similar to zillow, the key is to find the tool that provides the information and user experience that best suits you. From xome vs zillow to homebot vs zillow, the ecosystem of real estate sites similar to zillow is vast and varied.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Zillow or Redfin more accurate for home value?
This is the central question in the zillow vs redfin estimates debate. Both Zillow’s Zestimate and the Redfin Estimate are AVMs, not appraisals. Zillow publishes a national median error rate of 1.94% for on-market homes. The accuracy of both estimates varies significantly by location depending on the amount of available data. Neither is definitively more accurate in all situations; it’s best to use both as a starting point. The question of is zillow or redfin more accurate for home value can only be answered on a market-by-market basis.

Are Zillow and Redfin owned by the same company?
No, are redfin and zillow owned by the same company is a common misconception. They are publicly traded, independent companies and are direct competitors in the real estate tech space.

Is Realtor.com more accurate than Zillow?
When comparing realtor vs zillow home value estimates, both platforms use sophisticated algorithms, but their accuracy can differ based on the data available in a particular area. No platform’s estimate is guaranteed to be more accurate than the other in every market. The question of is realtor com more accurate than zillow has no definitive answer.

Are Zillow and Trulia the same?
Zillow and Trulia are owned by the same parent company, Zillow Group, but they are not the same. They operate as separate brands with different websites, apps, and user interfaces. Trulia focuses more on neighborhood data, while Zillow offers a broader, end-to-end "super app" experience.

Why do Realtors not like Zillow?
The sentiment that why realtors don’t like zillow is complex and not universally true. Many agents build successful businesses through Zillow. The friction that exists often stems from a few key areas: the Zestimate, which consumers sometimes mistake for an appraisal, and Zillow’s business model of selling leads through its Zillow Premier Agent program. Some agents feel the cost of leads is high, while others find the service invaluable. Zillow’s data shows that agents using the platform close more transactions than those who don’t, indicating a strong partnership for many.

What is the most accurate real estate website?
There is no single "most accurate" real estate website. For property listings, most major sites like Zillow, Redfin, and Realtor.com are highly accurate because they pull data directly from the MLS. For home value estimates, accuracy is a moving target that varies by location.

What is Zillow’s biggest competition?
Zillow’s main competitors, or zillow top competitors, in the online portal space are Redfin and Realtor.com. Each represents a different business model, making the zillow competition landscape diverse. Beyond portals, Zillow also competes with traditional brokerages and other technology companies.

Is there a better app than Zillow?
"Better" is subjective and depends on user needs. By the numbers, Zillow has the #1 U.S. residential real estate app, with four times more daily active users than the next competitor. However, some users might prefer the interface of a redfin competitor or another one of the other apps like zillow.