Kidizen vs. Poshmark vs. Mercari: Which is Best for Parents?

Kidizen vs. Poshmark vs. Mercari: The Ultimate Reseller’s Guide

by

The online resale market is booming, offering a fantastic way to declutter your home, earn extra cash, and contribute to a more sustainable world. For parents and fashion lovers, three platforms often rise to the top: Kidizen, Poshmark, and Mercari. But which one is the right fit for your items and selling style? Whether you’re trying to figure out where to sell kids clothes or liquidate a varied wardrobe, choosing the right marketplace is key to your success.

This comprehensive guide breaks down the essential differences between these three resale powerhouses. We’ll compare their fees, shipping processes, target audiences, and unique features to help you decide where you should list your items for maximum profit and minimal hassle.

Table of Contents

At a Glance: Kidizen vs. Poshmark vs. Mercari

Feature Mercari Kidizen Poshmark
Primary Niche Everything (electronics, collectibles, home goods, fashion, etc.) Kids’ clothing, shoes, accessories, and maternity wear. Primarily clothing, shoes, and accessories for all ages.
Seller Fee 10% selling fee (effective Jan 6, 2025). 12% + $0.50 marketplace fee. $2.95 for sales under $15; 20% for sales $15 and over.
Shipping Flexible; seller or buyer pays with variable rates via USPS, UPS, FedEx, or ship-on-your-own. Seller sets price or uses calculated shipping; seller pays for label. Buyer pays a flat rate for USPS Priority Mail (up to 5 lbs).
Community Transaction-focused; direct messaging available. Highly community-oriented with groups and forums. Very social; relies on sharing, following, and virtual "Posh Parties."
Best For Sellers with a wide variety of items beyond fashion. Sellers focused exclusively on kids’ and moms’ items. Fashion-focused sellers who enjoy social engagement.

Deep Dive: Mercari, The Everything Marketplace

Mercari positions itself as "your marketplace," a versatile platform designed to help you declutter your home by selling almost anything. With over 50 million downloads in the U.S. and more than 350,000 new items listed daily, it’s a massive and active marketplace. The philosophy is simple: if you’re no longer using it, someone else might treasure it.

The selling process on Mercari is streamlined into three straightforward steps:

  1. Sell It: Listing an item is always free and can be done in minutes. You snap a few photos, write a description, and set your price.
  2. Ship It: Once your item sells, Mercari emails you a printable shipping label. You then have three business days to package the item and ship it.
  3. Get Paid: After the buyer receives the item, they have three days to confirm it’s as described and rate you. Once they do, the funds are added to your balance.

A major draw for sellers is Mercari’s robust seller protection. This includes free listings, trusted transactions where payments are securely processed, and hassle-free shipping options that include up to 0 in Shipping Protection. This makes selling on Mercari and Poshmark a common strategy, but many sellers find Mercari’s protections compelling. For high-end items, Mercari Authenticate offers a service where luxury goods are reviewed by professionals, earning a diamond badge that helps them sell faster.

Deep Dive: Kidizen, The Niche for Kids’ & Moms’ Style

If your inventory is overflowing with outgrown children’s items, Kidizen is a must-know platform. It is a dedicated marketplace for buying and selling gently used kids’ fashion, shoes, accessories, books, toys, and even maternity wear. Many sellers consider it the best kidizen alternative to more general marketplaces.

The platform is built around a strong parent community. Beyond just transactions, users can follow favorite shops, join groups based on interests or location, and get styling advice. A unique feature is the "Style Scout" program, where experienced sellers can sell items on consignment for other local parents, making it a great way to sell used kids clothes online without the hands-on effort. The overall feel of the kidizen app is more boutique and community-driven than its larger competitors. If you’re wondering what is Kidizen, think of it as a specialized, social hub for parents.

Deep Dive: Poshmark, The Social Fashion Hub

Poshmark is a social commerce giant built around the love of fashion. While it has expanded to include home goods and electronics, its heart and soul remain in clothing, shoes, and accessories. So, what is Poshmark and Mercari? While both sell clothes, Poshmark’s experience is fundamentally social.

Success on Poshmark often involves more than just listing an item. Sellers are encouraged to "share" their listings (and others’) to their network of followers, participate in themed "Posh Parties" to gain visibility, and engage with other users. This social aspect can be a major advantage for sellers who are willing to be active on the platform.

Many parents ask, is Poshmark good for selling kids clothes? The answer is yes. Poshmark has a dedicated kids’ category, and many buyers specifically search the platform for children’s brands. While not as hyper-focused as Kidizen, it provides access to a much larger user base that might be shopping for the whole family, making it a strong contender for the best place to sell kids clothes online.

Fee Showdown: Mercari Fees vs. Poshmark vs. Kidizen

Understanding the fees is critical to calculating your potential profit. The difference between Mercari and Poshmark in this area is significant.

  • Mercari: As of January 6, 2025, Mercari charges a flat 10% selling fee on the final item price plus any buyer-paid shipping. Buyers are charged a separate 3.6% Buyer Protection fee. There are also fees for specific services like Instant Pay ($3) and a $2 fee for failed direct deposits.
  • Kidizen: This platform charges a marketplace fee of 12% + $0.50 on the listing price. This straightforward structure is easy to calculate when pricing your kidizen clothes.
  • Poshmark: The fee structure is simple: for sales under $15, Poshmark takes a flat fee of $2.95. For sales of $15 or more, the fee is 20%. This is a key point in the poshmark vs mercari selling debate, as Poshmark’s 20% is higher than Mercari’s 10%.

This brings us to a crucial question for sellers: how much does mercari take vs poshmark? On a $50 sale, Mercari would take $5, while Poshmark would take $10.

Shipping & Logistics Compared

How you get your item to the buyer is another major point of difference.

  • Mercari: Mercari offers the most flexibility. Sellers can use Mercari’s prepaid labels, which offer significant discounts (up to 40% off retail) with USPS, UPS, and FedEx. These labels come with tracking and up to $200 in Shipping Protection. Sellers can also choose to ship on their own, which is ideal for oversized items. For convenience, Mercari provides QR codes for UPS and USPS shipments, so you don’t even need a printer.
  • Poshmark: Poshmark simplifies shipping with its PoshPost label. The buyer pays a flat-rate shipping fee for USPS Priority Mail for any package up to 5 lbs. This is incredibly simple for sellers—you just print the label and ship—but offers no flexibility on carrier or service type.
  • Kidizen: Sellers on Kidizen have more control. You set your own shipping price when you list an item, which gets added to the total for the buyer. You can build shipping into your price and offer "free" shipping, or charge a flat rate. You are responsible for purchasing the label yourself.

Audience & Niche: Who Shops Where?

Knowing your audience is key to making sales. The platforms attract different types of buyers.

  • Mercari: The audience is incredibly broad. People come to Mercari to find anything and everything, from a specific video game to a vintage handbag. It’s the digital equivalent of a massive, nationwide garage sale and flea market combined.
  • Kidizen: The shoppers here are highly targeted: parents, grandparents, and caregivers looking specifically for children’s and maternity items. They are often knowledgeable about kids’ brands and looking for quality second-hand pieces. This is why many consider it the best place to sell used kids clothes online.
  • Poshmark: The typical Poshmark buyer is fashion-savvy and often brand-conscious. They are looking for deals on specific styles and brands, from J.Crew to Louis Vuitton. The social nature of the platform means many buyers follow specific "Poshers" whose style they admire.

Expanding Your Reach with Cross-Listing

Many savvy resellers don’t limit themselves to a single platform. The practice of cross-listing—listing the same item on multiple marketplaces simultaneously—is a powerful strategy to increase visibility and sell items faster. While the platforms themselves don’t offer a built-in tool, sellers often manually list their items or use third-party inventory management software to streamline the process.

Common cross-listing strategies include:

  • Cross list from Kidizen to Mercari: Move a kids’ item that isn’t getting traction on the niche site to the broader audience on Mercari.
  • Cross list from Poshmark to Kidizen: A strategy for those who want to target the specific parent audience on Kidizen for their children’s items.
  • Cross list from Mercari to Kidizen: Similar to the above, this is for sellers who want to specifically target the kid-focused market.
  • It’s also common to import Kidizen to Mercari or import Mercari to Kidizen when first expanding to a new platform to quickly build up inventory.

The Verdict: Which Platform Is Best for You?

So, what is better mercari or poshmark? Or should you be on Kidizen? The best platform truly depends on what you’re selling and your preferred selling style.

  • Choose Mercari if… You sell a wide variety of items beyond just clothing (like electronics, toys, collectibles, and home goods). You prefer a straightforward, transaction-focused process with flexible, low-cost shipping options and a lower selling fee. This is the platform for the ultimate declutterer.
  • Choose Kidizen if… Your inventory consists almost exclusively of kids’ clothing, shoes, accessories, or maternity wear. You value a tight-knit community feel and want to sell to a highly targeted audience of parents.
  • Choose Poshmark if… You are a fashion enthusiast with a curated closet of women’s, men’s, or kids’ clothing. You enjoy the social aspect of selling—sharing, following, and engaging—and don’t mind the higher 20% commission in exchange for its large, fashion-focused audience and simple shipping.

Ultimately, there’s no reason to choose just one. Many successful sellers use a combination of these platforms, leveraging each for its unique strengths.

Frequently Asked Questions

How does Kidizen work?
Sellers list kids’ or maternity items on the app. When an item sells, the seller ships it directly to the buyer. Kidizen facilitates the payment and takes a 12% + $0.50 fee from the sale.

Is Kidizen legit?
Yes, Kidizen is a legitimate and well-regarded online marketplace for parents to buy and sell new and gently used children’s items. It has a strong community and is considered safe for transactions.

Do children’s clothes sell well on Poshmark?
Yes, children’s clothes can sell very well on Poshmark. The platform has a large, dedicated category for kids and babies, and many shoppers browse for their entire family, making it a profitable space if you have desirable brands.

What is the difference between Mercari and Poshmark?
The main differences are in their niche, fees, shipping, and community. Mercari is a general marketplace for "almost anything" with lower fees and flexible shipping. Poshmark is a social marketplace focused on fashion with higher fees and a standardized, flat-rate shipping system.

Do you make more money on Poshmark or Mercari?
This depends on the item’s price. Due to Mercari’s lower 10% fee versus Poshmark’s 20% fee (on items over $15), you will generally keep more of the sale price on Mercari. The selling on poshmark vs mercari debate often comes down to whether Poshmark’s larger fashion audience can command a higher price to offset the higher fee.

Is it better to sell on Mercari or Poshmark?
It depends on your items and selling style. Is Poshmark or Mercari better for selling clothes? Poshmark’s social features and fashion-focused audience can be better for clothing, but Mercari’s lower fees and broader audience are also very effective. For variety, Mercari is superior.

Is Mercari or Poshmark better for buying?
For buyers, both platforms are excellent for finding deals. The poshmark vs mercari choice often comes down to what you’re looking for. Poshmark is great for fashion discovery and specific brands, while Mercari is better for a wider range of goods and potentially lower prices due to the lower seller fees.