Spotting a Fake OfferUp Profile: Red Flags to Watch Out For

Spotting & Avoiding Fake Profiles on OfferUp: A Complete Guide

by

OfferUp has revolutionized the way we buy and sell locally, connecting millions of users through its convenient mobile marketplace. It’s a fantastic platform for finding great deals and decluttering your home. But with its popularity comes an unfortunate side effect: the presence of scammers and fraudulent accounts. Understanding how to spot fake profiles on offerup is no longer just a helpful skill—it’s essential for a safe and successful experience.

Many new users ask, is offerup legit? The platform itself is a legitimate and widely used service, but like any online marketplace, it attracts individuals with malicious intent. This guide will walk you through everything you need to know about identifying and avoiding scammers on offerup, so you can buy and sell with confidence.

Table of Contents

Understanding the Risk: Are There Scammers on OfferUp?

Let’s address the big question first: are there scammers on offerup? The answer is yes. No online peer-to-peer platform is completely immune to fraudulent activity, and it’s important for users to be aware of the potential risks. While OfferUp has implemented safety features like user verification and in-app messaging, scammers constantly evolve their tactics.

The primary reason for scams on offerup is the direct nature of transactions, which can be exploited. Knowing how common are scams on offerup can be difficult to quantify, but awareness of the common methods is your best defense. The good news is that most scams share common warning signs. By learning what to look for, you can significantly reduce your risk and have a secure experience. The key is to approach every transaction with a healthy dose of caution and to understand the platform’s safety guidelines.

Red Flags: How to Spot OfferUp Scams and Fake Profiles

Knowing how to spot offerup scams starts with scrutinizing a user’s profile and communication style. Scammers often leave a trail of clues. Here are the most critical offerup scam signs to watch out for, which can help you identify potential offer up fake accounts.

1. The Profile Looks Suspicious

  • New & Empty Accounts: A profile created "this month" with no ratings, no purchase/sale history, and no verifications is a major red flag. Legitimate users typically have some history.
  • Generic or No OfferUp Profile Picture: Scammers often use generic stock photos, pictures of models, or leave the profile picture blank. A real person is more likely to use a genuine photo.
  • Lack of Verifications: OfferUp’s "TruYou" verification adds a layer of trust. Be cautious of users who haven’t verified their identity, email, or phone number.
  • Vague or Gibberish Usernames: Usernames like "John S19472" or a random string of letters can indicate a quickly made, disposable account.

2. Communication Feels "Off"

  • Pressure to Move Off-App: This is the biggest red flag. A scammer will immediately try to get your phone number or email to "talk more easily." This is done to get you off OfferUp’s monitored platform and into a space where they can send phishing links or execute other scams. Be especially wary of offerup fake buyers asking for phone number.
  • Urgency and Pressure Tactics: They might claim they have other buyers lined up or need to sell immediately to pressure you into making a hasty decision without proper vetting.
  • Poor Grammar and Spelling: While not always a definitive sign, messages riddled with grammatical errors and awkward phrasing can indicate a scammer operating from overseas.
  • Refusal to Meet in Person (for local items): For local listings, a user who makes endless excuses to avoid a public meetup and insists on shipping is highly suspicious.

3. The Listing or Offer is Too Good to Be True

  • Unbelievably Low Prices: A brand-new iPhone for $200? A high-end laptop for 80% off? These are almost certainly scams designed to lure in victims.
  • Stock Photos for Used Items: Legitimate sellers will post actual pictures of the item they are selling, including any flaws. Scammers often use pristine, professional stock images they pulled from the internet.
  • Vague or Copied Descriptions: A lack of detail in the item description, or a description that seems copied and pasted from a manufacturer’s website, can be a sign of a lazy scammer.

Learning how to identify scams on offerup is about recognizing these patterns. Trust your intuition—if a user or a listing makes you feel uneasy, it’s best to walk away.

How to Tell if an OfferUp Buyer or Seller is Legit

Once you’ve screened for the initial red flags, you can dig a little deeper to confirm a user’s authenticity. Following this checklist is key to figuring out how do you know if someone is legit on offerup.

  • Step 1: Thoroughly Check Their Profile: This is the most critical step. Look at their join date, their verification badges (especially TruYou), and what other items they might be selling. A well-established profile is a good sign.
  • Step 2: Know How to Check Reviews on OfferUp: This is your best tool for vetting someone. Tap on a user’s name to view their profile, where you can see their star rating and read comments from other buyers and sellers. Look for detailed, positive reviews offerup. A history of successful transactions speaks volumes. Pay attention to both what the offerup reviews say and how many there are.
  • Step 3: Ask Specific Questions About the Item: This is how to tell if offerup seller is legit. A real seller knows their item inside and out. Ask for a specific detail not in the description, an extra photo from a certain angle, or the reason they are selling. Scammers with fake listings will often give vague answers or be unable to provide more details.
  • Step 4: Analyze Their Communication: A legitimate user will communicate clearly and professionally within the app. They will be willing to answer your questions and arrange a safe transaction. This is a crucial part of determining how to tell if offerup buyer is legit, as they should be respectful and not overly pushy. For sellers, this is how to know if offerup seller is legit; they should be transparent and helpful.

If a buyer or seller checks all these boxes, you can proceed with much greater confidence.

Common Scams on OfferUp to Look Out For in 2025

Scammers use a variety of schemes to trick users. Being aware of these common scams on offerup will help you recognize and avoid them. As we look ahead, these are the offerup scams 2025 will likely continue to feature.

  • The OfferUp Verification Code Scam: This is one of the most prevalent scams on offer up. A "buyer" will contact you and say they need to verify you’re a real person. They’ll ask for your phone number so OfferUp can "send you a code." In reality, they are trying to create a new OfferUp or Google Voice account using your phone number. They trigger the verification process, and if you give them the code sent to your phone, they gain control of an account linked to you. Never share verification codes with anyone.
  • Overpayment Scams: This classic offer up scam targets sellers. A buyer, often one of the many offerup fake buyers, will claim they "accidentally" sent you too much money through a third-party app (like Zelle or Cash App) and ask you to refund the difference. The initial payment was fraudulent and will eventually be reversed by the bank, leaving you out both the "refunded" money and your item if you shipped it.
  • Fake Payment Confirmation Emails: This is a popular type of offerup seller scams. A buyer will claim they’ve paid (often for a shipped item) and you’ll receive a very convincing-looking fake email from "OfferUp" or "PayPal" confirming payment. They pressure you to ship the item quickly. Always verify payment inside the official OfferUp app or your payment app, never trust an email.
  • Bait and Switch: This happens during in-person meetups. The seller lists a high-quality, often brand-name item. When you meet, they present a lower-quality, damaged, or counterfeit version, hoping you won’t notice or will feel too awkward to back out of the deal.
  • Phishing Scams: By luring you off the app, scammers will send you links to fake websites that look like OfferUp or a payment processor. They’ll ask you to log in or enter your financial information, effectively stealing your credentials.

Knowing what are the scams on offerup, from buyer scams on offerup to schemes targeting sellers, is the first step in protecting yourself.

Getting Scammed on OfferUp: Your Next Steps

Despite your best efforts, getting scammed on offerup can happen. If you find yourself in this unfortunate situation, it’s important to act quickly.

Here’s what to do if you get scammed on offerup:

  1. Stop All Communication: Do not engage with the scammer any further. Block their profile immediately.
  2. Report the User in the App: This is the most direct action you can take. Knowing how to report scammer on offerup is crucial for community safety. Go to the user’s profile, tap the three dots in the corner, and select "Report." Provide as much detail as possible about the scam.
  3. Contact OfferUp Support Directly: File a support ticket with OfferUp’s customer service team, explaining the situation and including the user’s name and any relevant screenshots of your conversation.
  4. Report the Incident to Authorities: If you lost a significant amount of money, file a report with your local police department. You should also report the internet crime to the FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3).
  5. Notify Your Bank or Payment Provider: If the transaction involved your bank, credit card, or a service like PayPal, contact their fraud department immediately. They may be able to reverse the charge or otherwise assist.

Understanding what happens if you get scammed on offerup is about taking these decisive steps to mitigate the damage and help prevent the scammer from victimizing others.

Is OfferUp Safe? Best Practices for Buyers and Sellers

So, with all this in mind, how safe is offerup? Ultimately, the platform is as safe as you make it. By following established best practices, you can create a secure environment for your transactions. Whether you’re wondering is it safe to buy from offerup or is it safe to sell on offerup, these universal rules apply.

For Buyers – Is OfferUp Safe for Buyers?

  • Meet in Public: Always arrange to meet at a busy, public location, preferably one designated as a Community MeetUp Spot (often at a police station or busy retail store).
  • Inspect Before Paying: Thoroughly inspect the item to ensure it matches the description and is in the expected condition before you hand over any money.
  • Pay with Cash or In-App: For local meetups, cash is often safest. For shipped items, always use OfferUp’s in-app payment system, which offers buyer protection. Avoid third-party apps like Zelle, Venmo, or Cash App, as they offer no protection for goods and services.

For Sellers – Is OfferUp Safe for Sellers?

  • Vet Your Buyer: Check the buyer’s profile and reviews before agreeing to a sale. Be wary of red flags for fake buyers.
  • Don’t Ship Until Paid: For shipped items, never send your product until you see the payment confirmed within the OfferUp app. Do not trust email confirmations.
  • Meet Safely: Just like buyers, sellers should insist on meeting in a safe, public location. Bring a friend if possible.
  • Avoid Holding Items: Scammers may promise to pay later if you hold an item. It’s best to operate on a first-come, first-served basis with verified users.

By being vigilant, you can confidently say that offer up legit transactions happen every day. Your safety is paramount, and these steps are your best defense against the offer up scams that exist.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can you get scammed on OfferUp?
Yes, it is possible. Like any online marketplace that connects individual buyers and sellers, there is a risk of encountering scammers. Following safety guidelines like checking reviews, communicating within the app, and meeting in public significantly reduces this risk.

Are there fake buyers on OfferUp?
Yes. Scammers often pose as buyers to perpetrate scams, such as the overpayment scam or the verification code scam. These offerup fake sellers and buyers use new or empty profiles and will often pressure you to move the conversation off the platform.

What are the biggest red flags for fake buyers?
The three biggest red flags are: immediately asking for your phone number to communicate outside the app, offering to pay more than the asking price (often as part of an overpayment scam), and using a brand new profile with no history or ratings.

Is it safe to give my phone number on OfferUp?
No, it is strongly advised against it. Keeping all communication within the OfferUp app protects your personal information and creates a record of the conversation that OfferUp support can review if a problem arises. Giving out your number exposes you to phishing attempts and the offerup verification code scam.

How do you know if someone is legit on OfferUp?
A legitimate user typically has a profile that has been active for a while, a collection of positive ratings and reviews from past transactions, verified information (like TruYou), and is willing to communicate politely and transparently within the app.