Share This Post, Help Others, and Earn Credits!

Are you crafty? Do you have things you have personally made and would like to sell them? If you answered yes to both of those questions, then you're in luck. There are two outstanding companies that you can sell your things on and make a profit. Amazon Handmade and Etsy are two of the most popular websites when it comes to selling their items. Since both of them are the best, how do you decide on a company to sell your precious items on? You will learn a little bit about both companies throughout this guide so you can make an informed decision on which one has your business.

Let's dive right in.

amazon handmade vs Etsy

When it comes to handmade products, there are two e-commerce giants that come to mind: Amazon Handmade and Etsy. Both platforms offer a unique marketplace for artists and artisans to sell their wares, and both have a loyal following of shoppers. But which one is the better option?

To help you decide, let's take a closer look at Amazon Handmade vs Etsy.

What is Amazon Handmade?

You may have things to sell but you don't have a clue what Amazon Handmade is. It's an online store that you can access from Amazon's website to sell some of your things. This company was born with a crafty person in mind. Before we get to the products, you will learn some advantages and disadvantages of this company to understand a little more about it before you start signing up for an account.

The Advantages of the Amazon Handmade Process

  1. There's no fee. When you list things for sale on Amazon Handmade you don't have to pay a fee for each item you post.
  2. Your listings don't expire. Here's some more good news. Whatever you post will be there forever until someone purchases them.
  3. Access to Amazon's customers. When listing something on Amazon Handmade, you already have customers that will look at your things. Amazon's customers will look through and see what they might need for their homes.

The Disadvantages of the Amazon Handmade Process

  1. You have to apply. If you're interested in selling your crafty items through Amazon Handmade, you have to apply first. You're not able to post anything up for sale until it is approved.
  2. You are required to pay a fee. When you're filling out your application, you will see a spot to fill out your payment information. Yes, that's right. You do have to pay a fee of around 40 dollars to submit your application. The good news is once your application is approved, you will get your money back.
  3. Not too many people know about it. Even though you can get to Amazon Handmade through Amazon, not too many people know about that section of Amazon. People will have to search for it under the drop-down on Amazon before they will see it.

What is Etsy?

Now that you understand a little bit about Amazon Handmade, we'll move on to Etsy. Etsy is very similar to Amazon Handmade. You can post things you're selling on Etsy and make a profit. Below you'll find out about the advantages and disadvantages of the process and you will come closer to making your decision on which one to choose.

The Advantages of the Etsy Process

  1. Etsy attracts a different amount of people. People go on Etsy when they want to purchase something that they can personalize, and they can find things that are not sold in stores because they're coming from you.
  2. You can post things for people to download. If you have stationary you want to sell, then you can charge people a small fee for them to download. This process works with anything paper-related that you want to sell for people to download.
  3. It's an easy process. When you sell on Etsy, it's easy to do. You can have your things up for sale in a matter of minutes. All you have to do is create an account and start posting your things.
  4. List things privately. You have the option to list things privately on Etsy. A customer may purchase a lot of things from you or you may know another seller that also sells things on their Etsy account. You can send the listing to that person privately. Only they will be able to see it, and they will have the first chance to purchase it.
  5. Automatic renewal. Another great thing about Etsy is that Etsy will automatically renew the projects that you have listed. If it's been a few months and you still haven't sold them, Etsy will renew your handmade items so you won't forget about the renewal date.

The Disadvantages of the Etsy Process

  1. Etsy charges you. For every item you post, Etsy will charge you a fee of 20 cents before it is listed for sale. If you are selling things by the unit, Etsy will charge you around 20 cents per unit.
  2. Your items will expire. Remember that anything you post for sale, will not be available forever. Etsy will take it off of their website unless you select the auto-renew feature. The automatically renew feature will get your listing back on the website. That's one of the advantages you will find out above.

What Kinds of Products Does Amazon Handmade Sell?

To determine whether or not you have products to sell on Amazon Handmade or Etsy, you should become familiar with the products you are allowed to sell. On Amazon Handmade, you can only sell handmade things. For example, toys or games that are made with wood or dishes that are built with your two hands. Selling things on Amazon Handmade does have its advantages and disadvantages.

The Advantages of Selling Products on Amazon Handmade

  1. It's easy to add personalized products on Amazon Handmade. When posting your personalized products, you can create a customized text option. This way other people will be able to enter what they want on the product. With these fields, it makes it easier for you to know exactly what your customer wants.

The Disadvantages to Selling Products on Amazon Handmade

  1. There's a higher market. Since there are thousands and thousands of people that shop on Amazon every day, it can be hard to get your projects noticed. Everyone that sells on Amazon Handmade competes with you because there may be several people posting the same type of item you are selling.
  2. You can only sell certain items. Amazon Handmade only allows you to put things up for sale that are made from wood or more of a designer type. You can't sell E-books or downloadable things. Products that you list for sale should be packaged to send to the customer.

What Kinds of Products Does Etsy Sell?

In this section, you will learn about the advantages and disadvantages of selling on Etsy. The information you will find below will get you one step closer to choosing the platform you feel more comfortable selling on.

The Advantages of Selling Products on Etsy

  1. You can sell anything you want. Aside from Amazon Handmade, you can sell anything and everything you want. You can even post some samples of your work for free if you want. If you do that, be sure to add a watermark to your picture so no one will take your design.
  2. Millions of customers purchase things from Etsy every day so you are guaranteed that your work will be noticed. Be sure to have a generous price for your products because people like to make price comparisons. It's best to make sure you're pricing things that are not too expensive but not too cheap.

The Disadvantages to Selling Products on Etsy

  1. Etsy takes over your online store. Unfortunately, you don't have control over your store and what happens to your items. Etsy has the right to revoke a certain item if it doesn't meet its rules or regulations. They don't have to give you a warning. They may even go back and forth with the customer to answer their questions about your products.
  2. You have to come up with the right SEO words. As you're posting a product, you will get to choose tag words. These tag words will help a customer go straight to your item. It can be difficult when several other items have the same SEO word. It makes things hard because potential customers will have trouble finding your product.
  3. Pricing is competitive. Other sellers are always trying to outprice one another.

How to Signup on Amazon Handmade?

Does this information sound good so far? You may be curious about how you can signup to start posting things for sale. We'll go through the advantages and disadvantages of the signup process, and then we'll move along to the Etsy category.

The Advantages of the Signup Process on Amazon Handmade

  1. Becoming successful at owning your products in your online shop. As you go through the signup process, you will notice that you will see different pricing options. When you select the professional plan, you will become aware of the number of tools and support needed to help you throughout your business venture.
  2. Build a profile. Once your application has been approved, you can create a profile letting potential customers know a little bit about yourself and the kinds of items you selling. If they know your back story, they will be more likely to purchase something from you.

The Disadvantages of the Signup Process on Amazon Handmade

  1. Amazon has a long approval process. When you start listing things for sale, potential customers don't get to see them right away because it takes a while before your application gets approved. It could take up to two weeks or longer.
  2. There's no guarantee your application will be approved. You could be spending a while waiting for your application to be approved and you find out that it was rejected. It could be rejected for a few reasons. For example, it will be rejected if your application does not follow their rules and regulations meaning adding fake information.

How to Signup on Etsy

Now it's time to learn how the signup process works on Etsy. As you're reviewing the information, think about a few questions. Is it easier than Amazon Handmade? Can you start posting things right away? Is the signup process lengthy? We'll cover the advantages and disadvantages of the signup process on Etsy and you will uncover if it will be worth it signing up.

The Advantages of the Signup Process on Etsy

  1. You are provided with tools to start listing immediately. All new users will receive a guide that will walk you through owning your shop on Etsy.
  2. The signup process is easy. It's easy to sign up, and it's free. You will have to register for a new account and follow the instructions when prompted to do so.

The Disadvantages of the Signup Process on Etsy

  1. There are a few fees. While it is free to register for an account, there are a few fees you must pay to start listing your products for sale. A couple of those fees include a listing fee and a transaction fee. As mentioned earlier, you will need to pay 20 cents to list your products. When a buyer buys your products, Etsy will receive 5 percent of your profit.
  2. Your business could become saturated. Nowadays more and more people are turning their hobbies into things they can sell and using Etsy as a place to have their online store. When there are too many people selling things similar to what you made, it makes it harder for you to have a slight edge.

Amazon Handmade vs Etsy: The Pros

Now that we've taken a look at what each platform is, let's compare the pros of Amazon Handmade vs Etsy.

+ Amazon Handmade Pros

  • Amazon is a household name. This means that there is already a built-in customer base of people who are familiar with the Amazon brand and trust it.
  • Amazon is a one-stop shop. Customers who are looking for handmade products on Amazon can also buy items like books, electronics, and groceries. This convenience is a major selling point for Amazon.
  • Amazon offers Prime shipping. This benefit is a huge advantage for Amazon Handmade sellers because it means that their products can be shipped for free to Prime members, who are also more likely to be Amazon customers.
  • Amazon Handmade has lower fees. Etsy charges a listing fee of $0.20 per item, as well as a 3.5% transaction fee and a payment processing fee of 2.9% + $0.30. Amazon Handmade, on the other hand, only charges a 12% referral fee.

+ Etsy Pros

  • Etsy has a more intimate feel. Because it is a smaller platform, Etsy has a more tight-knit community of sellers and buyers.
  • Etsy attracts a certain type of shopper. People who shop on Etsy are specifically looking for handmade, vintage, or unique items. This makes it easier to target your audience on Etsy than on Amazon.
  • Etsy offers more tools for sellers. For example, Etsy has a built-in blog feature and allows sellers to create coupon codes and sales.
  • Etsy is more lenient with its rules. Etsy has less strict guidelines than Amazon Handmade, which means that there is a wider range of products that can be sold on the platform.

Amazon Handmade vs Etsy: The Cons

Of course, no platform is perfect, and there are also some cons to consider for Amazon Handmade vs Etsy.

- Amazon Handmade Cons

  • Amazon is a competitive marketplace. Because anyone can sell on Amazon, the platform is very competitive. This can make it difficult for handmade sellers to get their products noticed.
  • Amazon has strict requirements. In order to sell on Amazon Handmade, sellers must meet certain requirements, such as only selling handmade products.
  • Amazon can be impersonal. Because it is such a large platform, Amazon can feel impersonal and overwhelming. This can be a turn-off for some shoppers.

- Etsy Cons

  • Etsy can be challenging to stand out. Because Etsy is full of handmade sellers, it can be difficult to make your products stand out from the crowd.
  • Etsy attracts a certain type of shopper. While this can be seen as a pro, it can also be a con because it means that you may have to work harder to attract buyers who are not specifically looking for handmade products.
  • Etsy fees can add up. Etsy charges listing fees, transaction fees, and payment processing fees, which can add up, especially for small sellers.
  • Etsy is not a one-stop shop. Because Etsy specializes in handmade, vintage, and unique items, shoppers who are looking for other types of products will not find what they are looking for on the platform.

Amazon Handmade vs Etsy: The Bottom Line

So, which platform is the better option: Amazon Handmade vs Etsy? The answer depends on what you are looking for. If you are looking for a platform that is convenient and offers a wide range of products, Amazon Handmade is a good option. However, if you are looking for a more intimate community and easier platform to use, Etsy may be a better choice.

Concluding Thoughts

Now that you have fully understood what it takes to sell things on Amazon Handmade vs. Etsy, the real question enters your brain. Is it better to sell on Etsy or Amazon? Only you can answer this question. It depends on what you're selling to decide which one you should go with. You may want to sell your things on both platforms to gain extra revenue. You could sell your crafted, wooden items on Amazon Handmade and downloadable ideas on Etsy.

Try these free tools by Topbubbleindex

If you're looking to get started with print-on-demand, Topbubbleindex is the perfect place to begin. We offer all the digital marketing tools you need to be successful, and we're committed to keeping them free forever. Below, you'll find a few of the free tools we offer to help you get ahead of the competition and make sales easily.

And still counting! If you're still not impressed, try the Topbubbleindex tools for free. Don't hesitate to contact us for suggestions, complaints, or just feedback. We are always working on to keep the Topbubbleindex better.

Related Articles

What is Instagram Shopping? Instagram Shopping is a powerful feature allowing businesses to create a seamless shopping experience within the app. You can tag products directly in your posts, Stories, Reels, and even livestreams. Customers can tap on the tags to view product details and prices, and then click through to purchase on your Etsy shop. Adding Etsy Products to Facebook & Instagram Shop: Connect your Etsy shop to Facebook: ...


Understanding Redbubble What is Redbubble? Redbubble is an online marketplace that empowers independent artists to sell their work on a vast range of print-on-demand products. The beauty of this model lies in its simplicity: you, the artist, upload your designs, and Redbubble takes care of the rest—production, fulfillment, shipping, customer service, and even payment processing. Redbubble boasts a global community of over 800,000 artists, connecting them with millions of customers worldwide. This offers immense potential for exposure and reaching a wide audience, but...


What is a Visa gift card? A Visa gift card is a prepaid card that can be used to make purchases anywhere that accepts Visa. It's a great option for gifting, budgeting or if you simply don't want to use your credit or debit card. ...


Redbubble: Pros and Cons Pros: Huge Organic Traffic: Redbubble remains one of the biggest names in POD, attracting millions of visitors searching for unique artwork on a vast array of products. This translates to a greater chance of organic sales without heavy marketing investment. Personalized Shops: Unlike some platforms, Redbubble allows you to create a personalized storefront, building your brand identity with custom banners, logos, and shop descriptions. This fosters customer loyalty and increases brand recognition. Control Over Shop: Redbubble grants you extensive control...


Society6 in Detail What is Society6? Society6 is a vibrant online marketplace where independent artists can showcase and sell their work on a diverse range of high-quality print-on-demand products. Since its founding in 2009, it has become a go-to platform for creatives to connect with a global audience and generate passive income from their art. Society6 distinguishes itself with its expansive product catalog, featuring not only common POD items like t-shirts and mugs but also unique offerings like furniture, shower curtains, and...


Etsy's Shipping Prices ExplainedEtsy has been known to be one of the most expensive places to shop for handmade goods. A lot of people are wondering why shipping is so expensive on Etsy. Shipping costs on Etsy are calculated based on the weight of the item, the shipping destination, and the shipping method. Etsy also offers insurance for items that are lost or damaged in transit. Shipping costs are automatically calculated by Etsy when a listing is created. Some sellers...


Redbubble: Art-Centric Marketplace Founded in 2006, Redbubble is an Australian-based POD platform that has become a hub for independent artists and designers. Its focus leans heavily towards artistic expression, with a vast marketplace filled with unique art prints, graphic designs, and creative products that cater to a community seeking one-of-a-kind items. Platform Highlights Effortless Design Upload and Product Creation: Redbubble is renowned for its ease of use. Uploading designs and applying them to multiple products is incredibly straightforward. The bulk upload feature streamlines...


I. Understanding Your Product and Sourcing Method Before diving into the intricacies of Instagram vs. Etsy, it’s crucial to take stock of your business fundamentals. A clear understanding of your target audience, product type, and sourcing method will pave the way for making a strategic platform choice. Define your target audience Who are you trying to reach? What are their demographics (age, gender, location)? What are their interests, passions, and needs? Understanding your ideal customer is the cornerstone of effective marketing and product...


I. Introduction Print-on-demand has revolutionized the way creators monetize their designs. Gone are the days of hefty upfront investments, risky inventory stockpiles, and the logistical headaches of shipping. POD platforms handle all the backend complexities, allowing you to focus on what you do best—creating captivating designs. Redbubble and Teespring stand out as two of the most popular POD services, both offering a free and intuitive way to design and sell custom products. But despite their shared core functionality, they differ significantly in...


I. Understanding the Key Differences: Depop vs. Etsy While both Depop and Etsy operate as online marketplaces, they differ significantly in terms of their target audience, product focus, fee structure, and overall selling experience. Understanding these nuances is essential for choosing the platform that best aligns with your business goals. Target Audience Depop: Picture a bustling online community where fashion-forward Gen Z and millennials reign supreme. Depop thrives on its youthful and trendy vibe, attracting a digitally savvy demographic that embraces secondhand fashion...


1. Understanding the Landscape of Etsy Scams Etsy’s success has, unfortunately, made it an appealing target for scammers. The platform boasts a massive user base of both buyers and sellers, many of whom are drawn to the allure of handmade, unique goods. This inherent trust in handcrafted items, combined with the potential for less tech-savvy users on a creative platform, creates an environment that scammers can exploit. Moreover, scammers prey on human emotions. They know that buyers are excited to find deals...


Top and best 20 Etsy jewelry shops 1. EVREN It is a British Columbia brand that has been on the Esty since 2016. ith this shop, you will get impressive, minimalistic, and...


Create an EyeCatching Profile Your profile is one of the first things potential customers see when they visit your shop. Make sure your profile photo is professional and easy to see. Add a short bio that tells visitors a little about you and ...


Understanding the Power of Print-on-Demand Print-on-demand is a revolutionary business model that eliminates the risks associated with traditional manufacturing. Instead of investing in bulk inventory, POD platforms allow you to create products only when a customer orders them. This means no upfront costs, minimal storage needs, and the freedom to experiment with diverse designs and product lines. Here’s how it works: You create a design and upload it to a POD platform, where it’s applied to a range of products like t-shirts,...


Understanding the Business License Landscape Before diving into the specifics of Etsy, let’s first define what a business license is and why it matters for entrepreneurs. What is a Business License? In essence, a business license is an official document issued by a government authority that grants you permission to operate your business legally. It’s like a stamp of approval, confirming that you’re following the rules and regulations set forth for businesses in your area. Depending on the type of business you’re running...


Why Redbubble Is The Best Solution For Print On Demand There are many reasons to choose Redbubble as your go-to print on demand provider. They offer a wide variety of products that can be printed on, from clothes to phone cases to home decor. They also have ...


What are the requirements FOR Etsy payout? IN ORDER TO receive payment FROM Etsy, you must FIRST meet the requirements FOR Etsy payout. TO be eligible FOR Etsy payout, you must: ...


As a buyer, will you receive a refund? If you are a buyer on Etsy, there is a chance that you may be scammed. This can happen if you buy an item that is not as described, or if the seller does not send the item. If you are scammed on Etsy, you may be ...


How can you make money on Redbubble? There are a few different ways that you can make money on Redbubble. The most common way is to sell your own designs on a variety of products, such as t-shirts, stickers, phone cases, and more....


Why sell food on Etsy? Etsy is a great marketplace for food producers for a few reasons. First, Etsy has a large audience of potential buyers - over 35 million active buyers worldwide. This means ...


The two most popular ecommerce platforms for artists and makersThere are a ton of ecommerce platforms out there, but when it comes to selling handmade goods, there are really only two that stand out: Big Cartel and Etsy. Both platforms have their pros and cons, so it's important to choose the one that's right for your business. In this article, we'll compare Big Cartel vs Etsy, and help you decide which platform is right for you.The similarities and differences between...


When you're first starting out selling online, it can be tough to decide which platform is right for you. Etsy and Amazon are both popular options, but they have very different features and benefits. In this article, we'll compare Etsy and Amazon,...


Views vs Visits: Which is More Important for Etsy Sellers?When you're running an Etsy shop, it's important to track your analytics so you can see what's working and what's not. Two key metrics you'll want to pay attention to are views and visits. But what's the difference between the two, and which one is more important for Etsy sellers? Read on to find out.Introduction: What are views and visits, and how are they measured on Etsy?Views and visits are both...


Step By Step Guide On How To Leave A Review On Etsy A review, also known as feedback, lets Etsy sellers know what some of their customers think of their products. If you have received something fabulous from an Etsy seller and want to...


How much does Etsy charge for shipping? Etsy has a few different shipping options available, and the price you pay will depend on the shipping method that you choose. The first option is First Class Mail, which is the cheapest option available. First Class Mail...


Understanding Etsy vs. Pinterest Etsy and Pinterest are distinct platforms, each with its strengths and limitations. Understanding their unique characteristics will help you leverage their combined potential for Etsy marketing success. Etsy: Definition: Etsy is an online marketplace where buyers and sellers connect to trade handcrafted, vintage, and unique items. It’s a community-driven platform, with a strong emphasis on creativity and craftsmanship. Strengths: Community Focus: Etsy fosters a sense of community, with buyers and sellers sharing their passion for unique items. Unique Products: Etsy offers a...


Top 30 digital products to sell on Etsy 1. eBooks Selling eBooks is a great way to make money on Etsy. You can sell eBooks on any topic, from how-to guides to ...


What is Etsy? Etsy is an ecommerce platform that's focused on selling handmade, vintage, or supplies for creative businesses. Etsy is similar to other ecommerce platforms like Shopify or Amazon, but it has a few key differences. ...


Best Etsy Tools For Sellers Etsy Trends Finder Searching for keywords that people are searching for that match your product or service can be an effective way to get your product or service on the...


How To Cancel Etsy Order As A Buyer If you need to cancel an Etsy order, you can do so through the Etsy website or app. The process is simple and takes just a few minutes to complete. There are a few reasons why you might need to cancel an Etsy ...


Ebay: the good, the bad, and the ugly eBay is the world's largest online marketplace, where you can buy and sell just about anything. The good news is that there are millions of potential buyers on eBay. The bad news is that there are also millions ...


Etsy Alternatives for Crafty EntrepreneursEtsy isn't the only place to sell handmade and vintage items online. If you're looking for other sites like Etsy to sell your products on, here are 6 great alternatives.ArtFireAbout ArtFire: ArtFire is a marketplace where you can sell handmade goods, vintage items, and craft supplies. ArtFire has been around since 2008 and has a community of over 1 million members.ArtFire Pros:No listing feesYou can offer coupons and discountsA variety of membership plans to choose fromDetailed...


Why you might want to have more than one Etsy shop There are a few reasons why you might want to have more than one Etsy shop. Perhaps you want to specialize ...


What Is Etsy? Etsy is an online marketplace that's more on the customer-to-customer (C2C) or peer-to-peer (P2P) e-commerce side, according to Statista. Etsy started in 2005 and had an exciting...


Which one is right for you? Etsy is a great platform for businesses that sell handmade, vintage, or unique items. If your products fit into one of these categories, then Etsy is likely a good fit for you. Squarespace is a good option...